When She Was Me: By Marlee Bush

When She Was Me by Marlee Bush is a psychological thriller that delves into the dark and complex relationship between twin sisters, Cassie and Lenora. Set in an isolated Tennessee campground, the sisters have been living a reclusive life ever since a traumatic event from their childhood. Their world is upended when a teenage girl named Tilly goes missing from a neighboring cabin, bringing back haunting memories and suspicions. The narrative alternates between past and present, gradually revealing the sisters’ shared history and the chilling events that tie them to the present mystery. The plot is noted for its twists and turns, keeping readers guessing until the very end​​.

Characters

Cassie and Lenora are compelling characters whose bond is as intense as it is troubled. Cassie feels responsible for Lenora’s agoraphobia, a condition that confines Lenora to their cabin. The arrival of new characters, such as the ill-fated Tilly and her family, introduces external pressures that test the sisters’ loyalty and secrecy. Reviews highlight the depth of the characters, particularly the psychological tension between the twins. The dual perspectives and multiple timelines add complexity to their characterization, as each sister’s narrative unveils more about their past and their perspectives on the unfolding events​.

World-Building

The setting of the remote campground in Tennessee is integral to the novel’s eerie and claustrophobic atmosphere. Bush’s descriptive writing vividly brings to life the isolated woods, enhancing the suspense and sense of danger. Reviewers have praised the atmospheric quality of the book, noting how the setting amplifies the psychological horror elements. The campground serves not only as a backdrop but as a character in itself, reflecting the isolation and entrapment felt by Cassie and Lenora​.

All in all

When She Was Me is a gripping debut by Marlee Bush that masterfully blends suspense with deep psychological insights. The novel’s strength lies in its intricate plot, well-drawn characters, and atmospheric setting. It’s a slow burn that pays off with a series of shocking revelations and a satisfying, if unsettling, conclusion. Fans of psychological thrillers and suspenseful narratives will find this book hard to put down. Whether you’re drawn to the dark secrets of family bonds or the suspense of a well-crafted mystery, When She Was Me delivers on both fronts​.

Also Read: A Crane Among Wolves: By June Hur