This Is Why We Lied: By Karin Slaughter (Book Review)

Karin Slaughter’s This Is Why We Lied is the twelfth installment in the Will Trent series, bringing together the familiar protagonists, Will Trent and Sara Linton, in a gripping and suspenseful narrative. The story, set against the backdrop of a secluded mountain lodge, transforms a seemingly idyllic honeymoon into a harrowing murder investigation. Slaughter, known for her ability to weave intricate plots with deep character development, delivers yet another thrilling crime novel that keeps readers on the edge of their seats.

The Setting: A Perfect Getaway Turned Deadly

The novel is set in McAlpine Lodge, an off-the-grid mountaintop retreat that initially seems like the perfect place for Will and Sara to unwind after their wedding. However, the tranquility is shattered when the lodge’s manager, Mercy McAlpine, is found dead under suspicious circumstances. The isolation of the location, coupled with a fierce storm that cuts off access to the outside world, creates a classic “locked-room mystery” scenario, where the murderer is undoubtedly among the remaining guests​.

A Cast of Liars and Suspects

One of the novel’s central themes is deception. Every character, from the McAlpine family to the other guests, harbors secrets that they are desperate to keep hidden. Will and Sara, too, are not entirely truthful about their identities, choosing to conceal their professions as a detective and a medical examiner to avoid the usual reactions from others. This pervasive dishonesty adds layers of complexity to the investigation, making it increasingly difficult to discern the truth​.

Character Development and Emotional Depth

Slaughter’s strength lies in her ability to balance dark, disturbing narratives with deep emotional connections between her characters. The relationship between Will and Sara continues to evolve, showing a blend of tenderness and realism that adds a heartfelt dimension to the story. Despite the grim nature of their surroundings, the bond between the two protagonists provides a glimmer of hope and humanity amidst the chaos​.

Plot Twists and Suspense

As expected from a Karin Slaughter novel, This Is Why We Lied is filled with twists and turns that keep readers guessing until the very end. Slaughter’s knack for building suspense is evident throughout the novel, with each chapter unraveling new secrets and revealing more about the characters’ dark pasts. The narrative pace is relentless, making it difficult to put the book down once you start​.

Conclusion: A Masterful Addition to the Series

This Is Why We Lied is a complex, multi-layered story that not only delivers a compelling mystery but also explores the darker aspects of human nature. Fans of the Will Trent series will find this book a satisfying continuation, while newcomers might discover an enticing entry point into Slaughter’s world. The novel’s blend of suspense, emotional depth, and intricate plotting makes it a must-read for anyone who enjoys a well-crafted thriller​.

Also Read: By Any Other Name: By Jodi Picoult (Book Review)