For every cinematic high in the DC universe, like the illustrious Batman trilogy, there’s a low like Green Lantern that counterbalances it. Yes, nestled within DC’s vibrant array of superhero flicks are a handful of films that didn’t quite hit the mark. It’s easy to forget, given DC’s reputation for compelling narratives and larger-than-life characters, that not all movies can be blockbusters. So, let’s set aside the caped crusaders and justice leagues for a moment, and delve into the unexplored territory of DC’s less celebrated output. Brace yourself for a different kind of adventure as we count down the “10 Lowest Rated DC Movies on IMDb”. It’s a rough ride, but it’s one worth taking.
10 Lowest Rated DC Movies on IMDb
- Steel” (1997) – IMDb rating: 2.9/10
- “Catwoman” (2004) – IMDb rating: 3.4/10
- “Superman IV: The Quest for Peace” (1987) – IMDb rating: 3.7/10
- “Batman & Robin” (1997) – IMDb rating: 3.8/10
- “Supergirl” (1984) – IMDb rating: 4.4/10
- “The Return of Swamp Thing” (1989) – IMDb rating: 4.6/10
- “Jonah Hex” (2010) – IMDb rating: 4.7/10
- “Superman III” (1983) – IMDb rating: 5.0/10
- “Batman Forever” (1995) – IMDb rating: 5.4/10
- “Green Lantern” (2011) – IMDb rating: 5.5/10
Steel” (1997) – IMDb rating: 2.9/10
Kicking off our list of lowest-rated DC films on IMDb is “Steel” (1997), with a disheartening score of 2.9/10. Despite the promising premise of bringing the DC comic book character John Henry Irons to life, the movie fell flat. The adaptation, starring Shaquille O’Neal as the titular hero, didn’t resonate with audiences and critics alike, with criticisms largely focused on its unconvincing special effects, formulaic plot, and lackluster performances. Struggling to stay true to the source material while engaging a broader audience, “Steel” ended up losing its way. This early attempt at superhero cinema serves as a stark reminder of how difficult translating comic books to the silver screen can be.
“Catwoman” (2004) – IMDb rating: 3.4/10
Following “Steel” in our lineup of underwhelming DC endeavors is “Catwoman” (2004), with a slightly higher, yet still disappointing, IMDb rating of 3.4/10. This Halle Berry-fronted film intended to bring one of DC’s most enigmatic anti-heroines to life, but failed to deliver a compelling narrative or a faithful representation of the beloved character. Criticized for its lackluster plot, over-the-top acting, and over-reliance on style over substance, “Catwoman” is often cited as a prime example of how not to adapt a comic book character. Despite Berry’s considerable acting chops, the film failed to resonate with fans and critics, cementing its place in the annals of DC’s less successful cinematic ventures.
“Superman IV: The Quest for Peace” (1987) – IMDb rating: 3.7/10
Despite Christopher Reeve’s iconic portrayal of the eponymous hero, the film fell short due to its subpar storyline, substandard special effects, and a forgettable antagonist. It attempted to tackle weighty geopolitical issues with a simplistic lens, leading to its downfall. The noble intention to convey a potent message got lost amidst the lackluster execution. Despite its place in the legendary Superman franchise, it has unfortunately found a place on our list of DC’s lowest-rated movies.
“Batman & Robin” (1997) – IMDb rating: 3.8/10
Next up is “Batman & Robin” (1997), with an IMDb rating of 3.8/10, standing as a testament to the caped crusader’s less triumphant foray into cinema. Despite its star-studded cast, including George Clooney as Batman, the film failed to captivate audiences and critics alike. Widely criticized for its campy tone, over-the-top performances, and an excessively cluttered narrative, “Batman & Robin” strayed far from the dark and brooding tone usually associated with the Batman franchise. The film’s over-reliance on flashy visuals over cohesive storytelling led to its downfall, marking it as a notable low point in Batman’s otherwise impressive cinematic history.
“Supergirl” (1984) – IMDb rating: 4.4/10
Continuing our journey through the underbelly of DC’s filmography, we find “Supergirl” (1984), holding an IMDb rating of 4.4/10. The film, meant to spin-off from the successful Superman franchise, instead spun out of control. Despite its attempt to break the mold by introducing a female-led superhero movie, it missed its mark due to a convoluted plot, inconsistent characterization, and less-than-impressive special effects. While the intention to bring Supergirl to the big screen was commendable, the execution left much to be desired, making the film more of a stumble than a stride in the DC universe. It serves as a reminder that even with the best intentions, success isn’t always a guarantee in the world of superhero cinema.
“The Return of Swamp Thing” (1989) – IMDb rating: 4.6/10
Despite the success of the comic series and a prior film, this sequel failed to live up to expectations. With its blend of horror and campy humor, it fell short in capturing the nuanced storytelling and intricate characterization that made Swamp Thing a beloved anti-hero. Critics and fans alike were left underwhelmed by the movie’s cartoonish approach, substandard special effects, and a script that did little justice to its source material. Although it holds a certain charm for fans of B-movie aesthetics, “The Return of Swamp Thing” is widely considered a miss in the DC cinematic universe.
“Jonah Hex” (2010) – IMDb rating: 4.7/10
“Jonah Hex” (2010) makes an appearance on our list with an IMDb rating of 4.7/10, a clear sign of its less-than-stellar reception. Attempting to bring DC’s disfigured gunslinger anti-hero to life, the film fell short in terms of storytelling and character development. Critics pointed out the underdeveloped plot, lackluster special effects, and a general lack of depth in the titular character’s portrayal. Despite a stellar cast including Josh Brolin and Megan Fox, “Jonah Hex” failed to make a lasting impression. The film’s unsuccessful run is a reminder that even with promising source material, the leap from page to screen is not always a smooth ride.
“Superman III” (1983) – IMDb rating: 5.0/10
The penultimate entry on our list is “Superman III” (1983), standing with an IMDb rating of 5.0/10. Despite the charm of Christopher Reeve’s Superman and the addition of comedy icon Richard Pryor, the movie didn’t fly as high as its predecessors. Critics and fans agreed that the film’s overly comedic tone, confusing plot, and lack of a strong villain were its downfall. By straying too far from the essence of the Man of Steel, “Superman III” found itself losing altitude. This third installment serves as a reminder that maintaining a delicate balance between source material and cinematic innovation is key to a superhero film’s success.
“Batman Forever” (1995) – IMDb rating: 5.4/10
“Batman Forever” (1995) with an IMDb rating of 5.4/10. Despite featuring big names like Val Kilmer, Tommy Lee Jones, and Jim Carrey, this Batman installment failed to hit the high notes. Critics found the film’s overly flamboyant style, lack of a compelling storyline, and underdeveloped characters to be its primary shortcomings. Its tonal shift from the darker predecessors to a more campy and vibrant approach was met with mixed responses. While “Batman Forever” may have its fans, it’s largely viewed as a less successful chapter in Batman’s cinematic saga, thus securing its place in our lineup of DC’s lowest-rated films.
“Green Lantern” (2011) – IMDb rating: 5.5/10
Finally, bringing up the rear of our list is “Green Lantern” (2011), holding an IMDb rating of 5.5/10. Intended to kick-start a new superhero franchise, the film ended up receiving a lukewarm response from audiences and critics alike. Despite Ryan Reynolds’ best efforts, the movie was widely criticized for its underwhelming storyline, lackluster CGI, and failure to fully realize the potential of its source material. The film’s lackluster reception serves as a cautionary tale in the realm of superhero adaptations: a reminder that even with a compelling character and a charismatic lead, solid execution is key to resonating with audiences and standing up to the test of time.
Also Read: 10 Lowest Rated Marvel Movies on IMDb