Under the Oak Tree, Vol. 1: By Suji Kim (Book Review)

“Under the Oak Tree, Vol. 1” by Suji Kim is a compelling blend of romance and fantasy that has captivated readers worldwide. Originally a popular web novel, it has been officially translated into English and published in print, allowing a broader audience to experience its rich narrative and complex characters.

Plot Overview

The story centers on Lady Maximilian, known as Maxi, the daughter of Duke Croyso. Sheltered and demeaned due to her stutter, Maxi’s life takes a dramatic turn when she is compelled to marry Sir Riftan, a knight of humble origins entangled in her father’s political schemes. Their initial encounter is fraught with miscommunication and emotional distance, leading Riftan to depart abruptly the morning after their wedding. He returns three years later as a celebrated war hero, reigniting a complex relationship with Maxi as they navigate their shared life and personal growth.

Character Development

Maximilian (Maxi): Maxi’s journey from a timid, oppressed noblewoman to a more self-assured individual is a central theme. Her struggle with self-worth, exacerbated by her father’s abuse and societal expectations, is portrayed with sensitivity. As she acclimates to her new environment and responsibilities, readers witness her gradual empowerment and desire to assert her independence.

Riftan: Initially depicted as gruff and enigmatic, Riftan’s character unfolds to reveal a deep-seated affection for Maxi. His internal conflicts and the challenges he faces in expressing his emotions add depth to his persona. The evolution of his relationship with Maxi, moving from estrangement to a more profound connection, is a testament to his character development.

Themes and Motifs

The novel delves into themes of personal growth, healing from past traumas, and the transformative power of love. Maxi’s journey is emblematic of overcoming internal and external obstacles, while the evolving relationship between her and Riftan underscores the importance of communication and mutual respect. The medieval fantasy setting enriches these themes, providing a backdrop that highlights societal constraints and personal liberation.

Writing Style and Pacing

Suji Kim’s writing is immersive, with detailed descriptions that bring the medieval fantasy world to life. The narrative balances introspective character development with external conflicts, maintaining a steady pace that keeps readers engaged. Some readers have noted that certain plot developments are predictable, but the emotional depth and character arcs compensate for these aspects.

Reception and Critique

“Under the Oak Tree” has garnered a positive reception, with readers praising its character development and romantic elements. The novel holds a rating of 3.78 out of 5 on Goodreads, based on 1,404 ratings and 406 reviews. Reviewers have highlighted the emotional depth of Maxi’s journey and the chemistry between the protagonists. However, some critiques point to the prevalence of miscommunication between characters and a desire for more substantial plot progression beyond the romantic narrative.

Adaptations and Cultural Impact

The success of “Under the Oak Tree” extends beyond its novel form. It has been adapted into a webcomic, further broadening its audience and impact. The story’s exploration of personal growth and resilience resonates with readers, contributing to its popularity in the romantasy genre.

Conclusion

“Under the Oak Tree, Vol. 1” offers a richly woven tale of love, personal growth, and resilience set against a vividly imagined medieval fantasy backdrop. Suji Kim’s nuanced characters and engaging narrative invite readers into a world where personal transformation and romantic development take center stage. While the story leans heavily on romantic elements, the underlying themes of empowerment and healing provide a compelling read for enthusiasts of the romantasy genre.

Also Read: The Housemaid’s Wedding: By Freida McFadden (Book Review)