Two Sides to Every Murder: By Danielle Valentine

Danielle Valentine’s “Two Sides to Every Murder” is a gripping young adult thriller that intertwines the lives of two teenage girls, Olivia and Reagan, who are bound by a notorious murder case that occurred the night they were born. This novel delves into themes of family secrets, the search for identity, and the quest for truth, set against the backdrop of the infamous Camp Lost Lake murders.

Plot Overview

The narrative alternates between the perspectives of Olivia and Reagan. Olivia, born during the Camp Lost Lake murders, discovers that the man she believed to be her father is not her biological parent, prompting her to seek answers at the camp. On the other hand, Reagan has spent her life on the run with her mother, who is accused of the murders. Believing in her mother’s innocence, Reagan is determined to uncover the truth and clear her mother’s name.

Characters and Development

Valentine expertly crafts the characters of Olivia and Reagan, presenting them as distinct yet interconnected individuals. Olivia’s journey is driven by her need to uncover her true lineage, while Reagan’s is fueled by her desire to vindicate her mother. The author effectively explores the complex family dynamics and the psychological impact of the past on both girls. Their interactions are marked by initial distrust, gradually evolving into a reluctant alliance as they realize the depth of their connection.

Writing Style and Pacing in Two Sides to Every Murder

The book’s structure, with chapters alternating between past and present, adds depth to the mystery and keeps readers engaged. Valentine’s writing is fast-paced and tense, capturing the suspense and intrigue of the unfolding mystery. The inclusion of short chapters set on the day of the murders helps to provide context and deepen the reader’s understanding of the events that transpired.

Themes and Symbolism

“Two Sides to Every Murder” explores themes of truth versus perception, the impact of family secrets, and the struggle for identity. The setting of Camp Lost Lake serves as a symbolic place of both trauma and revelation, where buried truths come to light. Valentine’s portrayal of dysfunctional families and the psychological scars left by past events is both poignant and thought-provoking.

Reception

The book has been well-received by critics and readers alike. Reviewers have praised Valentine’s ability to create a compelling and atmospheric thriller that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. The character development and the intricate plot have been highlighted as major strengths of the novel.

Cristina Serratore from Books and Agita describes the book as a blend of “The Parent Trap” and a murder mystery, noting how the alternating viewpoints and the revelations about the characters’ families add depth to the story. The StoryGraph community reviews emphasize the dark, mysterious, and fast-paced nature of the book, making it a must-read for fans of YA thrillers and true crime mysteries.

Conclusion

“Two Sides to Every Murder” is a captivating thriller that combines a haunting mystery with deep character exploration. Danielle Valentine’s skillful storytelling and intricate plotting make this book a standout in the YA thriller genre. Whether you are a fan of true crime, dark family secrets, or psychological mysteries, this novel offers a gripping read that will keep you guessing until the very end.

Also Read: Shelterwood: By Lisa Wingate