The holiday-themed action-comedy Red One, starring Dwayne Johnson, Chris Evans, and Lucy Liu, has become the latest talking point in Hollywood, though not for the reasons its makers hoped. Despite its star-studded cast and $350 million budget for production and marketing, the film grossed a modest $34 million in its opening weekend in North America and has amassed $84 million globally since its November 6 international release. With an intriguing premise—featuring the rescue of Santa Claus from kidnappers by North Pole security chief (Johnson) and a hacker (Evans)—the film has yet to meet the lofty expectations set for it.
A Divisive Reception
Red One garnered mixed critical reception, with an A- CinemaScore and a 90% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes balancing out the generally negative reviews from critics. While some hailed its festive charm and positive word of mouth, others found its execution underwhelming. Analysts note that its opening numbers align with similar films led by Johnson, such as Jungle Cruise and Rampage. However, Red One‘s box-office trajectory is particularly critical, as it faces stiff competition in the coming weeks from major releases like Wicked, Gladiator 2, and Moana 2.
A Strategic Play for Amazon
Industry insiders suggest that theatrical profitability was never the primary goal for Red One. According to Variety, Amazon MGM aimed to use the theatrical release as a marketing tool to build buzz for the film’s debut on Amazon Prime Video. Positive audience reception could potentially translate to new Prime subscriptions and increased ad revenue, which Amazon hopes will offset its substantial investment.
Matthias Frey, head of the Department of Media, Culture, and Creative Industries at City, University of London, commented that if the streaming strategy fails, Amazon may reconsider future projects involving high-cost stars like Johnson, who reportedly earned $30 million upfront for the film, with potential earnings of up to $50 million from profits.
The Rock’s Rocky Career Trends
While Red One represents a unique challenge for Amazon, it also highlights troubling trends for Dwayne Johnson’s career. Once Hollywood’s most bankable action star, Johnson has faced a string of underperforming films, including Black Adam and Red Notice. Critics have pointed to a shift in his on-screen persona, where his focus on maintaining a “tough guy” image seems to overshadow the charm and self-deprecating humor that initially endeared him to audiences.
Reports of contractual stipulations in Johnson’s films—such as clauses ensuring he cannot lose a fight or appear weak—have further fueled this perception. A 2019 Wall Street Journal article revealed that Johnson, along with fellow Fast & Furious stars Vin Diesel and Jason Statham, requires equal punch counts and no outright defeats in their action scenes. While such demands might enhance an actor’s on-screen invincibility, they risk alienating audiences who crave vulnerability and relatability in their heroes.
Alleged On-Set Behavior Raises Eyebrows
Recent productions have also seen reports of on-set tensions involving Johnson, including clashes with co-stars like Chris Evans and Ryan Reynolds during the making of Red One and Red Notice. These claims, coupled with Johnson’s long-standing feud with Vin Diesel, have begun to tarnish his once pristine reputation as one of Hollywood’s most likable stars.
Interestingly, Johnson’s collaborations with female leads, such as Emily Blunt in Jungle Cruise, and comedic actors like Kevin Hart, seem to fare better both on- and off-screen, suggesting the tension may arise when he shares the spotlight with other leading men.
The Path Forward
Despite the struggles of Red One and other recent projects, industry experts believe Johnson has the potential to recapture his former glory. By leaning into his natural charisma and allowing himself to be the butt of the joke—traits that once made him a household favorite—Johnson could reverse the downturn in his career. For now, the fate of Red One rests on how well it performs on Amazon Prime Video.
Also Read: “Star Wars: Skeleton Crew” and Its Connection to “The Mandalorian”
