Men Have Called Her Crazy: By Anna Marie Tendler (Book Review)

Anna Marie Tendler’s memoir, Men Have Called Her Crazy, is a deeply personal exploration of mental health, womanhood, and the impacts of toxic relationships. Through a blend of candid storytelling and emotional introspection, Tendler invites readers into her world, marked by anxiety, depression, and the struggles of navigating life under the oppressive weight of societal expectations. This memoir, while often challenging, offers a raw and unfiltered glimpse into the author’s journey towards self-discovery and healing.

A Journey Through Mental Health

At the heart of Tendler’s memoir is her battle with mental health. The book opens with her admission to a psychiatric hospital in early 2021, a decision born out of desperation after a year plagued by severe anxiety, depression, and self-harm. Over the course of two weeks, Tendler undergoes various psychological assessments, participates in therapy sessions, and connects with other patients, leading to profound moments of realization and breakthrough.

Tendler’s account of her time in the hospital is both heartbreaking and enlightening. She details the fears, vulnerabilities, and moments of clarity that arose during her stay. The memoir also delves into the pivotal moments in her life that preceded her hospitalization, offering a fuller picture of the experiences that shaped her mental health struggles.

The Impact of Relationships

A recurring theme in Men Have Called Her Crazy is the impact of Tendler’s relationships with men. The memoir’s title is a reflection of the derogatory labels often placed on women by men, particularly when they defy societal norms or challenge their partners. Tendler recounts the significant relationships in her life, from unrequited high school love to the painful experience of losing her virginity to an older man, and the frustrations of dating in her mid-thirties.

While Tendler’s narrative is deeply personal, it also resonates with many women who have faced similar challenges in their relationships. The memoir doesn’t shy away from exploring the ways in which these relationships have contributed to her mental health struggles, offering a sobering look at the emotional toll of toxic masculinity.

Artistic Expression as Catharsis

Tendler’s background as an artist is woven throughout the memoir, with her experiences and emotions often expressed through her art. However, the book has been critiqued for sometimes undercutting the significance of her artistry by focusing too heavily on past relationships. Critics argue that while Tendler’s confessional writing style is compelling, it occasionally detracts from the exploration of her art’s role in her healing process.

Despite this, Tendler’s artistic voice remains a powerful element of the memoir, offering readers a window into how creativity can serve as a form of catharsis. Her detailed descriptions of her artistic endeavors provide a counterbalance to the darker themes of the book, highlighting the importance of finding solace and meaning in creative expression.

A Memoir of Mixed Reactions

Men Have Called Her Crazy has garnered a range of reactions from readers and critics. Some have praised Tendler’s unflinching honesty and the emotional depth of her writing, while others have noted that the memoir’s structure can feel uneven at times. The book’s focus on Tendler’s relationships with men, while central to the narrative, has also been seen as a limitation by some, who feel that it overshadows other important aspects of her life and experiences.

However, the memoir’s imperfections are also part of its appeal. Tendler’s willingness to share her story, flaws and all, makes Men Have Called Her Crazy a relatable and impactful read for those who have faced similar struggles. It is a testament to the complexity of the human experience and the ongoing journey towards self-acceptance and mental well-being.

Conclusion

Anna Marie Tendler’s Men Have Called Her Crazy is a powerful memoir that offers a raw and honest exploration of mental health, relationships, and the challenges of finding one’s place in the world. While the book may not resonate with everyone, it provides valuable insights into the experiences of a woman navigating the complexities of life with courage and vulnerability.

Also Read: The Spellshop: By Sarah Beth Durst (Book Review)