B.K. Borison’s “First-Time Caller” is a contemporary romance that intertwines the lives of a disenchanted radio host and a hopeful single mother, drawing inspiration from classic 90s romantic comedies. Set against the vibrant backdrop of Baltimore, this novel delves into themes of love, vulnerability, and the unexpected connections that can change one’s life.
Plot Overview
Aiden Valentine, once a firm believer in love, now finds himself disillusioned. As the host of “Heartstrings,” Baltimore’s late-night romance hotline, his cynicism poses a challenge. His routine takes an unexpected turn when Maya, a spirited 12-year-old, calls seeking dating advice for her mother, Lucie Stone. This heartfelt interaction goes viral, thrusting both Aiden and Lucie into the city’s spotlight. Lucie, a dedicated mechanic and single mother, is content with her life until the sudden public interest makes her question her own happiness. As she becomes a recurring guest on Aiden’s show, the two navigate the complexities of public scrutiny, personal desires, and the possibility of finding love where they least expected.
Character Development
Borison crafts her characters with depth and authenticity. Lucie Stone emerges as a resilient and relatable protagonist. Her journey from contentment to self-discovery resonates deeply, especially as she confronts vulnerabilities and opens herself up to new possibilities. Aiden Valentine, on the other hand, embodies the “grumpy” archetype, yet Borison provides insight into his disillusionment, making his transformation compelling. Their dynamic is enriched by witty banter and genuine moments of connection, making their relationship progression both believable and heartwarming.

Themes and Inspirations
Drawing inspiration from beloved 90s romcoms, notably “Sleepless in Seattle,” the novel pays homage to the era’s charm while infusing a modern sensibility. Themes of found family, personal growth, and the courage to embrace love are woven seamlessly into the narrative. Lucie’s close-knit community, including her supportive ex-husband and his partner, adds depth to the story, highlighting the beauty of unconventional family structures.
Writing Style and Pacing
Borison’s writing is both engaging and evocative. The dual perspectives of Lucie and Aiden offer readers a comprehensive understanding of their internal struggles and desires. Interspersed radio segments and online comments provide a unique narrative structure, adding layers to the storytelling. While the chemistry between the protagonists is palpable, some readers have noted that certain scenes feel prolonged, occasionally affecting the pacing. However, these moments are balanced by the novel’s heartfelt and humorous interactions.
Reception and Critique
“First-Time Caller” has garnered acclaim for its cozy and heartfelt narrative. Readers have praised its ability to evoke a sense of nostalgia while addressing contemporary themes. The novel’s strength lies in its character-driven storytelling and the authentic portrayal of relationships. Some critiques point to a desire for more exploration of Aiden’s relationship with Maya and a smoother transition into intimate scenes. Nevertheless, the overarching sentiment is one of appreciation for a story that balances humor, emotion, and romance.
Conclusion
B.K. Borison’s “First-Time Caller” offering a fresh yet familiar narrative that speaks to the heart. With well-drawn characters, witty dialogue, and a plot that celebrates love’s unpredictability, it stands as a delightful addition to contemporary romance literature. Whether you’re a fan of classic romcoms or seeking a heartfelt story of unexpected connections, this novel promises a rewarding reading experience.