By Any Other Name: By Jodi Picoult (Book Review)

Jodi Picoult’s By Any Other Name is a compelling and intricately woven tale that spans centuries, delving deep into the struggles of two women—one from the Elizabethan era and the other from contemporary times—both battling against societal norms to have their voices heard. The novel is a poignant exploration of identity, authorship, and the sacrifices women must make to see their work come to life.

A Tale of Two Women: Emilia Bassano and Melina Green

The novel alternates between the lives of Emilia Bassano, an Elizabethan poet who may have been the true author behind some of Shakespeare’s works, and Melina Green, a modern-day playwright in New York. Emilia, a woman ahead of her time, finds herself confined by the societal expectations of her era. Denied the opportunity to be recognized as a playwright, she strikes a deal with William Shakespeare to have her works performed under his name. Picoult paints a vivid picture of Emilia’s world—a time when women were expected to remain silent, their talents overshadowed by men. Emilia’s struggles are not just a fight for recognition but a battle for her very identity.

In contrast, Melina Green, living in a seemingly more progressive era, still faces her own set of challenges. Despite the progress made over four centuries, Melina finds that the world of theater remains largely dominated by men. Her play about Emilia’s life is dismissed when she attempts to have it produced under her own name. However, when her friend secretly submits the play under a male pseudonym, it is finally accepted, forcing Melina to navigate the complex dynamics of gender and identity in the modern world.

Themes of Feminism and Identity

Picoult’s novel is deeply rooted in feminist themes, as it examines the ways in which both Emilia and Melina are forced to conceal their true identities to achieve success. The narrative draws striking parallels between the past and present, highlighting how, despite the passage of time, women’s voices continue to be marginalized. The author masterfully portrays the internal conflicts faced by both women as they grapple with the decision to hide behind a male facade to be heard.

The book also raises important questions about the nature of authorship and the sacrifices required to bring one’s creative work to life. Picoult does not shy away from depicting the harsh realities faced by women in the creative arts, both historically and in contemporary society. Through Emilia and Melina’s stories, the novel explores the idea that true recognition often comes at a great personal cost, and the lengths to which women must go to see their work endure.

Strengths and Criticisms

By Any Other Name is richly detailed, immersing readers in the contrasting worlds of Elizabethan England and modern-day New York. Picoult’s ability to create fully realized characters is on full display, with both Emilia and Melina emerging as strong, relatable protagonists. The historical sections of the novel, particularly those focusing on Emilia’s life, are particularly compelling and showcase Picoult’s skill in bringing the past to life.

However, some critics have noted that the novel’s modern sections do not carry the same weight as the historical narrative. While Emilia’s story is filled with depth and emotional resonance, Melina’s struggles in the contemporary theater scene are sometimes portrayed as simplistic. Despite this, the novel remains a powerful exploration of the challenges faced by women across time and the enduring relevance of these issues.

Final Thoughts

Jodi Picoult’s By Any Other Name is a thought-provoking novel that will resonate with readers who appreciate stories about strong women fighting against the odds. The book is a testament to the enduring struggles for recognition and identity that women have faced throughout history and continue to encounter today. With its richly drawn characters and engaging dual timelines, By Any Other Name is a must-read for fans of historical fiction and those interested in the intersection of gender, identity, and creative expression.

Also Read: Wicked Serve: By Grace Reilly (Book Review)