In Big Dumb Eyes: Stories from a Simpler Mind, comedian Nate Bargatze trades his stage mic for a pen. The book isn’t chasing profundity—it’s a warm, lighthearted collection of personal essays and stories that invite readers to hang out with Bargatze as he unpacks childhood memories, family trivia, everyday quirks, and his trademark self-abasing humor. If you enjoy your comedy with a Southern drawl, zero cuss words, and a whole lot of sincerity, this book offers a comfortable seat next to Nate’s easy charm.
Clocking in at just 240 pages, this memoir takes the form of short anecdotes rather than a sweeping, chronological life story. Instead of a linear plot, expect a series of vignettes—some more polished than others—with plenty of comedic detours.
📚 Plot & Structure
While not plot-driven in the traditional sense, Big Dumb Eyes loosely follows Nate’s life journey—from his childhood in Old Hickory, Tennessee, to meeting his wife Laura, becoming a dad, and navigating adult responsibilities.
- Childhood & Family Ties: Nate paints a picture of life in a small Tennessee town, where a half‑inch of snow shut everything down and slushy sledding was community entertainment. His father, once a clown and magician known as “Yo‑Yo,” emerges as a figure of both amusement and inspiration—and we learn how Nate inherited his comedic flair.
- Sibling Rivalry & “My Sister the Alien”: One of the standout chapters, recounted in both the AP and Boston reviews, tells what happens when Nate, his brother Derek, and their dad accidentally leave their sister Abigail at church. They later find her “commune with the dead” at the cemetery—cue chaotic midnight retrieval.
- Career & Growing Up: Nate retells familiar bits from his stand‑up—like working as a water‑meter reader and his struggles with tipping and ordering at Starbucks. These moments give fans nostalgic echoes of his specials.
- Marriage & Parenthood: His relationship with Laura is a running thread, peppered with endearing footnotes in her voice (“…I can’t wait to see the look on his face”). He also lovingly describes parenting mishaps—like preserving Christmas magic for his daughter Harper, and learning the hard way how to ask family for ring money.
- Everyday Pet Peeves & Observations: From sock worries to stubborn fast‑food orders, Nate mines humor from the minutiae. These chapters are quick and quirky riffs rather than emotional deep cuts.
🎙️ Tone & Style
The book reads like a conversation with a funny friend—casual, unhurried, and familiar. His voice translates seamlessly to the page: low-key, self-effacing, and tinged with Southern warmth. He even admits in the intro: “I am very on the record about not liking to read books,” naming books as “so many words,” then reassuring readers they can approach the book “anywhere or any way”. The sometimes scattered structure mirrors his stage style—a series of comedic digressions tied together by personality, not plot.
That said, this approach isn’t for everyone. Some essays end abruptly, feeling half-told. Reviewers note that a few chapters are more stand‑up bits than memoir, lacking contextual depth . While that’s fine for comedic relief, readers seeking a cohesive narrative may find it patchy.
👍 Strengths: Why It Works
- Authentic, Beloved Persona
Nate’s likability bleeds off the page. Reviewers say he “looks like the underdog, so you root for him”, and that his voice feels like a genuine friend’s. - Clean, Family‑Friendly Humor
If you appreciate G‑rated, accessible comedy, this delivers. No swearing, no shock value—just observational humor spun naturally. - Memorable Chapters
Highlights like “My Sister the Alien,” “Raised by a Clown,” or “The Ballad of Old Blue” are both funny and touching—revealing Nate’s inner life while keeping it light. - Pacing & Readability
At around 222–240 pages with blank spaces and photos, it’s breezy. It’s ideal for short bursts—even elevator‑break style . - Southern Charm
From town quirks to snow panic stories, his Tennessee roots provide a foundation for universal laughter.
👎 Weaknesses: When It Falls Flat
- Inconsistent Depth
Some essays feel sketchy. Chapters like “Random Food Thing” are light but lack payoff. - Less Funny in Print
Many reviews note that his live stand‑up carries more bite. The humor here is gentler, and some jokes lose momentum outside his delivery . - Loose Structure
Without a narrative arc, some sections feel disconnected. A stronger thematic thread might’ve improved cohesion.
🧭 Who Should Read This?
- Fans of Nate Bargatze: If you love his specials (Your Friend Nate, Tennessee Kid) you’ll enjoy these stories expanded and fleshed out.
- Clean‑Comedy Lovers: Fans of Jim Gaffigan, Brian Regan, or Jerry Seinfeld—this shares their observational, family‑friendly style.
- Readers Seeking Light Escapes: Perfect for quick reading sessions. No emotional intensity required.
- Southern Story Enthusiasts: With its Southern voice and quirks, it stands out in the memoir/comedy genre.
Skip it if you want deep reflection or a tightly woven memoir.
⭐ Final Thoughts
Big Dumb Eyes doesn’t aim to solve the mysteries of the universe. It’s Nate Bargatze being Nate Bargatze—warm, bemused, charmingly clueless, and endearingly modest. The writing echoes his stand‑up: casually funny, relatable, and comfortable. Yes, you might wish for tighter editing or more meat—but the charm lies in its simplicity. It’s like trading stories with a good friend over coffee, with occasional belly laughs and an easy smile.
If you come to the book expecting a gently humorous look at life, filled with personal tales and friendly quips, you’ll find yourself grateful for the company. Nate Bargatze may have a “simpler mind,” but that doesn’t mean his book doesn’t leave a simple, pleasant aftertaste. 🙂
📚 Final Score: 4/5
- Read it for: Laughs, warmth, family stories, and Southern charm
- Skip it if: You’re after a profound memoir with tight structure and emotional depth.
Also Read: The Retirement Plan: By Sue Hincenbergs (Book Review)
